Skip to content
Home » Charred Meat: Is Removing Burnt Parts Enough for Health Safety?

Charred Meat: Is Removing Burnt Parts Enough for Health Safety?

  • Food
Reduce carcinogens in charred meat.


When grilling meat over charcoal, the appealing ‘smoky flavor’ comes with some health concerns. Many people enjoy the unique taste of charcoal-grilled food. However, they need to be aware of the carcinogens that this process can produce, particularly in charred meat.

1. Carcinogen Formation

Firstly, cooking meat or fish at high temperatures can create carcinogenic heterocyclic amines (HCAs). HCAs increase significantly when cooked above 200 degrees Celsius, a common scenario in outdoor charcoal grilling. The formation of HCAs can nearly triple at these high temperatures, making them a major risk factor in charcoal grilling, especially in charred meat. Secondly, even if the charred parts of the meat are removed, other carcinogens like polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) may remain. These substances can form when meat directly contacts flames and are also found in smoke. PAHs are also carcinogenic and an important factor to consider in the charcoal grilling process of charred meat.

2. Minimizing Carcinogens in Charred Meat

There are several methods to minimize the formation of carcinogens when grilling meat. These methods involve adjusting the cooking process and using additional ingredients to make a healthier meal.

Firstly, it’s advisable to partially cook the meat before finishing it on a low flame or in a frying pan. This approach reduces the formation of carcinogens such as HCAs and PAHs that can occur at high temperatures. Secondly, it’s preferable to sprinkle pepper on the meat after it’s fully cooked. Using pepper during the cooking process can increase the amount of another carcinogen, acrylamide. This risk arises from the transformation of certain seasonings at high temperatures. Thirdly, consuming vegetables like lettuce or parsley with the meat is also beneficial. These vegetables can mitigate the toxicity of carcinogens.

Additionally, marinating meat in herbs before grilling is recommended. Anticancer components like thymol and phenols in herbs can inhibit carcinogen formation. Crushing herbs and mixing them with lemon juice, wine, or vinegar to create a unique marinade is also a good option. Lastly, thoroughly cleaning the grill before and after cooking is crucial. The charred remains on the grill can contain carcinogens, so cleaning with specialized tools and rinsing with water is advised. This helps prevent the transfer of carcinogens in subsequent grilling sessions.

3. Summary

Grilling meat over charcoal, particularly charred meat, poses health risks due to carcinogens like HCAs and PAHs. Minimizing these risks involves methods like partial precooking, herb marination, and thorough grill cleaning to ensure a healthier grilling experience.